Jim On Film - May 16, 2002

Jim On Film
Page 1 of 2

by Jim Miles (archives)
May 16, 2002
Jim looks at the pros and cons of Disney's Broadway offerings.

Disney/Hyperion Theatricals: A History and Critique

The Shows

Beauty and the Beast
The stage adaptation of the classic Disney film has proved to be a popular family treat since its 1994 debut. It has since set out on two national tours, bringing new audiences to experience their first Broadway musical. Full of eye-popping visuals, breath-taking costumes, and beautiful music, Beauty and the Beast has become the tenth longest running show on Broadway. It was also nominated for an impressive nine Tony Awards; however, its singular win for costume design would come to signify Broadway’s hesitation with Disney on its stages. Despite this success, many theatre aficionados look upon the show as kiddie fare.

batb.jpg (14061 bytes)
(c) Disney

King David
Before The Lion King set foot on the New Amsterdam stage, a concert of a musical adaptation of the life of the Old Testament leader reached its stage with music by Alan Menken and lyrics by Tim Rice. Given only a limited run, selections of the show’s moving music were released on CD for a limited time. While it is hard to tell if the show can be considered a Disney show (it is listed in Dave Smith’s Disney A to Z, but the CD does not state Disney as the copyright owner), if it is, it would be nice to see Disney expand the presentation to a full-fledged musical.

lionking.jpg (20854 bytes)
(c) Disney

The Lion King
Known for her avant-garde use of masks and puppetry, Disney tapped into the talent of visionary Julie Taymor to direct the stage version of its successful 1994 film. Skeptics were quieted at the first sight of the amazing masks and costumes designed to create the illusion of elephants, birds, and lions. With a canon of new songs peppered with South African beats and lyrics, The Lion King stormed Broadway, winning six Tony Awards, including awards for Best Direction of a Musical for Julie Taymor and Best New Musical. Eventually, the demand for tickets to The Lion King was surpassed by demand for The Producers, but even today, tickets for the show are hard to come by.

The Hunchback of Notre Dame
Ending a very respectful run this June, The Hunchback of Notre Dame premiered in Berlin in 1999. Unlike Disney’s other film adaptations, with acclaimed writer and director James Lapine at the helm, the stage version of The Hunchback of Notre Dame differs in many key ways from the film, most of which make the show more Victor Hugo and less Walt Disney. According to various sites and articles devoted to the play, not only is Frollo a priest in this version, but he dies at the hands of Quasimodo. Furthermore, the gargoyles are renamed (rumor has it that Lapine wanted to get rid of them completely, but Disney resisted), and Esmeralda meets a sad fate as well. There has been much talk that Disney plans to film a television adaptation of the stage version before mounting one on Broadway.

aida.jpg (8391 bytes)
(c) Disney

Aida
In 2001, the Disney stage musical Aida won more Tony Awards than any other new musical that year. It took the awards for best music, best costumes, best lighting, and best lead actress in a musical. Despite an overwhelmingly positive audience response, the show received mixed reviews (some call it a Disney animated film on the stage--a statement that is hardly true) and was not even nominated for a Tony for Best New Musical. In the year when the dance review Swing! (hardly a true musical), the now-closed The Wild Party, and James Joyce’s The Dead (which had already closed by Tony time) were nominated, Tony voters couldn’t even find room for nominating Aida. In the end, the dance musical Contact won the award despite the fact that the show contains no live music, has little dialogue, and is comprised of three one-acts.

< Prev
1