Legacy Content

Toon Talk: Sword in the Stone 45th Anniversary DVD
Page 1 of 2

by Kirby Holt (archives)
June 17, 2008
Kirby reviews Disney's latest classic DVD release The Sword in the Stone 45th Anniversary DVD.
Toon Talk: Disney Film and DVD Reviews
by Kirby C. Holt

(c) Disney

The Sword in the Stone
45th Anniversary Edition
Disney DVD

Stone Cold

Stuck in-between 101 Dalmatians and The Jungle Book on the Disney animated feature list is The Sword in the Stone, easily the most uninspired of those produced during Walt Disneys lifetime. In fact, if it werent for the fact that it was indeed released in 1963, one could easily mistake it for another example of the fallow, after Walt years known as the 1970s.

Newly re-released on DVD as a 45th anniversary edition (available today), the film, based on the King Arthur legend as retold in T.H. Whites book of the same name, plays like a set-up for the inevitable wackiness of Jungle Book, regardless that the subject matter certainly calls for a different approach. On the other hand, the only time the film truly comes alive is in the raucous wizards duel between the daffy Merlin and the loony Mad Madame Mim. Only in this sequence, with the two practitioners of magic imaginatively transforming from one creature to another in a bid of prestidigious one-upmanship, does the film truly exploit the medium of animation to the fullest.

(c) Disney

Otherwise, we are confined to the rather pedestrian story of Wart, who, regardless of the fact that he is the once and future king, is without a doubt the blandest protagonist in all of the Disney canon. No wonder Merlin, winningly voiced in a most befuddled way by Karl Swenson, steals the movie, lock, stock and magical barrel.

Granted, the story of King Arthur has, before and after The Sword in the Stone, been told and retold on stage and screen so many times (see sidebar), that even at the time of this films release it was old hat. However, the angle of telling it from the perspective of Arthur as a boy should have generated something a bit more interesting. Or maybe he just needs a few knights and a round table to make his tale worth telling.


These two iconic characters of history, literature and legend have made many appearances, together and apart, on film throughout the years. Here are a few of their more famous portrayers:

  • A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthurs Court (1949): Cedric Hardwicke as Arthur
  • Knights of the Round Table (1953): Mel Ferrer as Arthur
  • 7 Faces of Dr. Lao (1964): Tony Randall as Merlin
  • Camelot (1967): Richard Harris as Arthur, Laurence Naismith as Merlin
  • Son of Dracula (1974): Beatle Ringo Starr as Merlin
  • Monty Python and the Holy Grail (1975): Graham Chapman as Arthur
  • Unidentified Flying Oddball (1979): Kenneth More as Arthur, Ron Moody as Merlin
  • Excalibur (1981): Nigel Terry as Arthur, Nicol Williamson as Merlin
  • Sword of the Valiant: The Legend of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight (1984): Trevor Howard as Arthur
  • Waxwork II: Lost in Time (1992): John Ireland as Arthur
  • First Knight (1995): Sean Connery as Arthur
  • A Kid in King Arthurs Court (1995): Ron Moody as Merlin, again
  • Kids of the Round Table (1995): Malcolm McDowell as Merlin
  • A Young Connecticut Yankee in King Arthurs Court (1995): Michael York as Merlin (and you read that right; four, count 'em, four Arthurian movies in 1995 alone)
  • Dragonheart (1996): John Gielgud as Arthur
  • Prince Valiant (1997): Edward Fox as Arthur
  • Quest for Camelot (1998): Pierce Brosnan as Arthur (with Steve Perry of Journey fame as his singing voice!), John Gielgud again, this time as Merlin
  • Merlin: The Return (1999): Patrick Bergin as Arthur, Young One Rik Mayall as Merlin
  • King Arthur (2004): Clive Owen as Arthur, Stephen Dillane as Merlin
  • The Last Legion (2007): Ben Kingsley as Merlin
  • Shrek the Third (2007): Justin Timberlake as Arthur, Eric Idle as Merlin


< Prev