Jim on Film
Page 5 of 5
(c) Disney
Phoebus, who was masterfully lead by animator Russ Edmonds, holds his own as a character against the courageous and scrappy Esmeralda. Phoebus has a great sense of humor about things, such as when Djali butts him in the stomach, and he says to Esmeralda, "I didn't know you had a kid.� He's also of high moral character, making him everything Frollo wants to be but never will be. His refusal to follow Frollo's orders to burn the miller's house, which he knows will cost him his life, is a very difficult decision. Even earlier, when he doesn't arrest Esmeralda and lies, saying that she has claimed sanctuary, Phoebus is proving his true colors. But what is more important to note is while he is vying for the woman the hero loves, there is never any animosity toward him. Just as the audience has fallen for Quasimodo, they have also fallen for Phoebus because he's such a rich character.
Lastly, a word must be said about Clopin, the narrator and master of ceremonies. Under the lead of animator Michael Surrey, Clopin is a fun and charming character whom, despite his limited role, the audience welcomes back throughout the course of the film. The introduction to his character on the streets of Notre Dame, which shows him to be a fun but insightful character, establishes him as an endearing sort. Even during The Court of Miracles, where he torments Quasimodo and Phoebus to the point of nearly executing them, one cannot hold too much of a grudge against such a jolly fellow.
It's also important to note that, despite several significant changes from Victor Hugo's original novel, which includes adding characters, altering characters, and making for a happy ending, this film adaptation is, at its heart, very much Victor Hugo. In college, after reading an abridged edition of his novel Les Miserables, it was very apparent that Hugo's mark is strongly pressed into the film in his concern for moral corruption and evil, his strong depiction of characters, for his Christian overtones, and his gritty portrayal of the oppressed classes.
The Hunchback of Notre Dame is a masterpiece at every level, from its strong thematic structure, to its music, visuals, and characters. While Hollywood analysts once called the film unsuccessful, it must be remembered that it did receive largely positive reviews on its release. Furthermore, it was interesting to see that upon its DVD reissue, critics were already beginning to see the film for the masterpiece it is, as the critic for USA Today noted that it didn't get the recognition that was worthy of in its first release, just as critics later said about Fantasia, Bambi, Sleeping Beauty, and others.
No, The Hunchback of Notre Dame probably isn't for the smallest of Disney fans, but taking into consideration its depth, richness, and beauty, that isn't a bad thing. In its construction, it is intended for the smartest of Disney fans. And its maturity is not found in its content but in its creation. As a result of this, it is probably more mature and complex than most films intended for adults.
And for that, we thank the filmmakers.
Discuss It!
Related Links
-- Jim Miles
Jim On Film is published every other Thursday.
The opinions expressed by our guest columnists, and all of our columnists, do not necessarily represent the feelings of LaughingPlace.com or any of its employees or advertisers. All speculation and rumors about the future of Disneyland and the Walt Disney Company are just that - speculation and rumors - and should be treated as such.
-- Posted June 19, 2003
Theme Park DVDs at
The LaughingPlace Store
The LaughingPlace Store carries theme park DVDs from Jeff Lange and many others featuring the best of Walt Disney World and Disneyland past and present.
LP Live Recent Picture
Posted: 3/21/10
Laughing Place Podcast
The LPP discuss the return of Captain EO, Alice in Wonderland, the new ESPN Wide World of Sports and ESPN the Weekend, their recent Disney Cruise, Listener Mail and the Rocket Rod Round. Sponsored by MouseEarVacations.com and HoJoAnaheim.com.