Peanut Butter Items Unavailable at Gideon’s Bakehouse Due to Recall

The ever-popular Gideon’s Bakehouse at Disney Springs is renowned for both its delicious cookies and its theming. Unfortunately, some of their most popular desserts are currently unavailable.

What’s Happening:

  • Each month, Gideon’s Bakehouse features a unique menu with different items, in addition to their regular fare. This month, the focus is on peanut butter, or at least it was.
  • Due to a recall, all bulk stock of peanut butter coming into the state of Florida has been slowed down.
  • As Gideon’s needs hundreds of pounds a day, there will temporarily be no peanut butter-based desserts available at the Bakehouse.
  • This includes Peanut Butter Crunch, Peanut Butter Chocolate Swirl, and the fantastic PB&J Cake Slices.
  • This issue likely won’t resolve until next week, and it will then take them a couple of days to ramp back up production.
  • To compensate, Gideon’s is adding the Coffee Cake and Dark Coffee Cake in greater numbers to both their Disney Springs and Downtown Orlando stores, as of today.
  • Due to how long those cookies take to make they will be available from open until they sell out, which may not be long at all.
  • To replace the PB&J Cake Slice, the Original Red Velvet Cake Slices will instead be available.
  • The popular Nitro Peanut Butter Cold Brew will still be available at Disney Springs, as it is made with peanuts from a favorite Georgia farm, not peanut butter.
Laughing Place recommends for all your Walt Disney World travel planning
Fill out the form below for a free,
no obligation quote from
Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.